8 ways to make cookies from a store-bought dough or mix taste homemade and look gourmet

You can upgrade your cookie dough by adding spices to it, said Tracy Wilk, lead chef at the Institute of Culinary Education. .

To do so, combine ground cinnamon, ginger, and sugar, and then roll your balls of cookie dough in the mix before baking. This can result in a warm, spicy cookie.

If you're feeling bold, you can even spice up your cookies with a sprinkling of cayenne pepper, said Jackie Newgent, chef and author of "The Clean and Simple Diabetes Cookbook."

To add depth to your cookies, add a few drops of a pure flavor extract to your dough, Newgent said.

This is a simple way to personalize the cookies to your liking or give them a unique twist each time you bake them. Some extracts to try include peppermint, lemon, vanilla, coffee, almond, or coconut.

Another way to add flavor or texture to your cookies is by rolling the balls of dough in your garnish of choice, Jennifer Hill Booker, chef, cookbook author, and culinary educator, told Business Insider. 

To start, you can try using chopped nuts, sanding sugar, miniature chocolate chips, cocoa powder, or sprinkles. 

For added texture, crunch, and color, stir nuts into your cookie dough.

Newgent said pecans, walnuts, and macadamia nuts can work — but, if you want a real homemade feel, you may want to use nuts that aren't commonly found in store-bought cookies, like pistachios. 

Mix-ins are another great way to add a unique flavor to a cookie and make it seem like you spent a lot of time making them.

"Plop in a surprise ingredient that you love, like crushed pretzels, potato chips, roasted chickpeas, or popped popcorn," Newgent told BI. 

Try topping cookies with a pinch of flaky sea salt before you put them in the oven, Newgent said.  

"Salt helps to balance sweetness, providing a more well-rounded taste and bonus deliciousness," she told BI.

Use a bit of melted chocolate to give your cookies a high-end look and homemade flavor, Wilk said. 

"Once the cookies are baked and cooled, dip them into chocolate or drizzle them with it," she said. "This will give a finished and fancy look without a lot of extra work."

Newgent told BI that if you really want to impress, you can use freshly grated citrus zest as a cookie topper.

She said orange pairs well with many chocolate cookies and lemon can elevate vanilla ones. 

"It'll make the cookies seem extra special and kind of fancy," she said. 

This story was originally published on May 15, 2020, and most recently updated on December 5, 2024.